Bug #10007
EVA Boarding fails
100%
Description
Pure unmodded KSP 1.1.3 on Win 7 pro, 64 bit. Upgraded from 1.1.2 by steam (not a fresh install), all files verified by steam.
Requirements to replicate the bug:
1) The attached rocket. I tried one other rocket, and EVA boarding worked correctly on it.
2) Launch from the ground. I really would like to provide a savegame in space, where you just have to EVA and try to board and watch it fail. But if you load a savegame in space, the bug does not happen.
3) Stage the rocket. If you do not stage away the SRBs, the bug does not happen.
To replicate: load the sandbox mode savegame (nuke_on_pad). It has a rocket on the pad. Verify that SAS is on, hit X to kill the second stage, and launch straight up. When the SRBs burn out, stage them away. When you reach space, EVA the pilot, then hit B to reboard the pod.
What happens: the pilot does not board the capsule, and remains on the ladder outside. The pilot cannot be accessed, and the controls move the rocket, not the pilot -- even when the game says that the pilot has focus. You can revert the flight. But if you try to click the button to go back to the Space Center it gives you the warning window that says "You are on a ladder, so the game cannot be saved at this point."
Related issues
History
#1 Updated by bewing over 8 years ago
Since this is an issue only for rockets that have been freshly launched from the ground, there are several workarounds. Switching focus to something else will destroy the ability to revert, but will prevent the bug. You can also take a savegame before any EVA, and if the EVA fails then reloading the savegame and doing the EVA again will succeed.
#2 Updated by gappleto97 over 8 years ago
- File KSP.log KSP.log added
- File Mobile Station Mk I Comms Module.craft Mobile Station Mk I Comms Module.craft added
- File Mobile Station Mk I.craft Mobile Station Mk I.craft added
- File persistent.7z persistent.7z added
bewing wrote:
Since this is an issue only for rockets that have been freshly launched from the ground, there are several workarounds. Switching focus to something else will destroy the ability to revert, but will prevent the bug. You can also take a savegame before any EVA, and if the EVA fails then reloading the savegame and doing the EVA again will succeed.
I got the same error while in space, from a not-freshly launched ship. The caveat there is that I have several mods installed, but looking at the logs, the error message is identical. The difficulty is that I can't reliably reproduce this in space.
Platform: Linux (kubuntu 16.04)Version: 1.1.3 (steam, from 1.1.2)
Mods installed:
- RemoteTech
- KerbalAlarmClock
- Kerbal Engineer Redux
- Better Engine Lighting
- EVSE
- RealPlume
- Scatterer
- SmokeScreen
- ModuleManager
Unfortunately, I do not have a Player.log to attach, but I will try to replicate the error. In the meantime, I will post the save/craft files and KSP.log.
To reproduce: EVA one of the Kerbals in the Hitchhiker capsule while in low orbit of Mun
#3 Updated by TriggerAu over 8 years ago
- Status changed from New to Updated
- % Done changed from 0 to 10
Be good to get a confirmation of this on an unmodded install using bewings repro steps
#4 Updated by Anth12 over 8 years ago
Confirmed
Windows 10 Pro
Steam version 1.1.3 Unmodded
Game save didnt work. went to black screen and never went to launch pad
Used supernuke2.craft and loaded it in VAB then used launch.
Launched straight up into space with SAS on.
Stage the rockets until theres just the nuclear engine left...made sure im past 70000m
eva...press B and valentina stays outside the ship.
LogFile attached with errors at 07:27:58.434
#5 Updated by TriggerAu over 8 years ago
- Related to Bug #10109: MPL EVA, Cloning Kerbals without Control added
#6 Updated by Claw over 8 years ago
Thanks for the report, I've been able to replicate here. It's the same sort of bug that was caused by the fairings and, in this case, has to do with the NERVA fairings.
#7 Updated by Claw over 8 years ago
- Related to Bug #10045: Clamp-O-Tron Fails to Function added
#8 Updated by sal_vager over 8 years ago
- Related to Bug #10055: Jeb appeared after EVA of a rescued kerbal that was alone in a MK1 pod during a rescue mission added
#9 Updated by sal_vager over 8 years ago
- Related to Bug #10214: Duplicate Kerbals on re entry to capsule after EVA added
#10 Updated by fommil about 8 years ago
- File Recover.craft Recover.craft added
I also experience this bug, originally reported here http://forum.kerbalspaceprogram.com/index.php?/topic/147248-kerbals-duplicating-on-eva-return/
It happens regularly for me when I send up a small probe to recover low Kerbin orbit kerbals.
Sometimes when a kerbal goes on EVA and tries to return to the vessel, I get control of the ship but the kerbal seems to stay outside the vessel and I cannot select them. They effectively die. It's really annoying I just hope I have a savegame that I can manually backup at that point then restart.
It is too erratic to be able to reliably reproduce, so I haven't been able to minimise my plugin set. My full list of plugins is (and latest versions in CKAN):
"name": "ModuleManager"
"name": "FerramAerospaceResearch"
"name": "ModularFlightIntegrator"
"name": "RemoteTech"
"name": "KerbalEngineerRedux"
"name": "SVE-Sunflare"
"name": "SVE-HighResolution"
"name": "Chatterer"
"name": "SCANsat"
I've attached the logs of what happens for the entire EVA and there are two exceptions, but I cannot see which module is causing the problem.
[LOG 21:15:30.961] [F: 24232]: [05:07:31]: Anchel Kerman from MunSci3 went on EVA.
[LOG 21:15:30.972] [ModularFlightIntegrator] MFI Start
[LOG 21:15:30.972] [ModularFlightIntegrator] Start. VesselModule on vessel :
ModularFlightIntegrator
FlightGUI
FARVesselAero
[LOG 21:15:30.972] Handling Stuff for KerbalEVA / Flag
[LOG 21:15:31.043] Adding vox box to Kerbal / Flag
[LOG 21:15:31.073] [FLIGHT GLOBALS]: Switching To Vessel Anchel Kerman ----------------------
[LOG 21:15:31.074] [PlanetariumCamera]: Focus: Anchel Kerman
[WRN 21:15:31.078] [Part]: kerbalEVA (Anchel Kerman) holds crew but has no interior model defined!
[LOG 21:15:31.093] [CHATR] Capsule starts the exchange...
[EXC 21:15:31.096] ArgumentOutOfRangeException: Argument is out of range.
Parameter name: index
System.Collections.Generic.List`1[UnityEngine.Renderer].get_Item (Int32 index)
Part.highlight (Color highlightColor)
Part.highlight (Boolean active)
Part.SetHighlight (Boolean active, Boolean recursive)
Part.SetHighlightDefault ()
KSP.UI.Screens.Flight.TemperatureGauge.OnDestroy ()
[LOG 21:15:32.184] Updating vessel voxel for Anchel Kerman
[LOG 21:15:32.312] Std dev for smoothing: 3 voxel total vol: 0.200000095367443 filled vol: 0.201879643291949
[LOG 21:15:33.715] [Experiments]: Setting FX Modules to 1...
[LOG 21:15:33.715] [Experiments]: FX Modules set: 1
[LOG 21:15:39.062] [Experiments]: Setting FX Modules to 0...
[LOG 21:15:39.062] [Experiments]: FX Modules set: 0
[LOG 21:15:39.063] [F: 24475]: [00:00:08]: Anchel Kerman boarded Mk1 Lander Can on MunSci3.
[LOG 21:15:39.063] [FLIGHT GLOBALS]: Switching To Vessel MunSci3 ----------------------
[LOG 21:15:39.064] [PlanetariumCamera]: Focus: MunSci3
[LOG 21:15:39.068] Camera Mode: AUTO
[EXC 21:15:39.083] ArgumentOutOfRangeException: Argument is out of range.
Parameter name: index
System.Collections.Generic.List`1[UnityEngine.Renderer].get_Item (Int32 index)
Part.highlight (Color highlightColor)
Part.highlight (Boolean active)
Part.SetHighlight (Boolean active, Boolean recursive)
KSP.UI.Screens.StageIcon.HighlightPart (Boolean highlightState)
KSP.UI.Screens.StageIcon.Highlight (Boolean highlightState, Boolean highlightReferencedPart)
KSP.UI.Screens.ProtoStageIcon.CreateIcon (Boolean alertStagingSequencer)
Vessel.ResumeStaging ()
Vessel.MakeActive ()
FlightGlobals.setActiveVessel (.Vessel v, Boolean force)
FlightGlobals.ForceSetActiveVessel (.Vessel v)
KerbalEVA.proceedAndBoard (.Part p)
KerbalEVA.BoardPart (.Part p)
KerbalEVA.<SetupFSM>m__C9 ()
KerbalFSM.RunEvent (.KFSMEvent evt)
KerbalFSM.updateFSM (KFSMUpdateMode mode)
KerbalFSM.UpdateFSM ()
KerbalEVA.Update ()
[LOG 21:16:07.368] UIMasterController: ShowUI
[LOG 21:16:07.368] Game Paused!
[LOG 21:16:07.369] There are Kerbals on a ladder. Cannot save
[LOG 21:16:10.447] Flight State Captured
#11 Updated by Squelch about 8 years ago
- Status changed from Confirmed to Ready to Test
- Target version set to 1.2.0
- % Done changed from 10 to 80
This was addressed and fixed for KSP 1.2
#12 Updated by JPLRepo about 8 years ago
- Status changed from Ready to Test to Closed
- % Done changed from 80 to 100
Closing as this was fixed in 1.2.0